The Bridgerton series by Julia Quinn has captivated many readers, especially since the Netflix adaptation aired. As a long-time fan of historical romance, I devoured the series in 2020 to prepare for the show.
I’ve always loved historical romance; it’s now my go-to genre, and I’m even wearing my historical romance sweatshirt as I write this.
Revisiting the Bridgerton series has been a delightful and insightful experience, especially seeing how my feelings have changed. Here’s my personal ranking of the Bridgerton books, from least favorite to most beloved.
8. The Duke and I
Starting with The Duke and I, this book is generally considered the weakest of the series. It introduces us to Daphne and Simon with a marriage of convenience plot.
While I enjoy fake dating scenarios, their fake dating phase felt too brief, quickly shifting to a marriage of convenience.
Despite the entertaining duel scene, the romance felt lacking. It served as a good introduction to the series, but it didn’t quite capture the magic of the later books.
7. Romancing Mr. Bridgerton
Romancing Mr. Bridgerton, which was a letdown for me. After three books of building tension between Colin and Penelope, their story fell flat.
Colin’s insecurity about his writing felt out of place, considering his privileged position. Despite some sweet moments, like Colin’s declaration of love for Penelope, the romance didn’t live up to the hype.
6. It’s in His Kiss
It’s in His Kiss features Hyacinth and Gareth’s charming romance. Hyacinth offers to translate for Gareth, leading to a sweet relationship.
The mystery element and Lady Danbury’s presence added flavor, but the romance didn’t stand out compared to others.
I enjoyed seeing Hyacinth as a main character, especially after her childhood appearances in previous books.
5. On the Way to the Wedding
Gregory’s story, On the Way to the Wedding, is heartwarming. Unlike his siblings, Gregory believes in love and is determined to find it.
He initially falls for Hermione but ends up with Lucy, Hermione’s best friend. The subplot of Gregory attempting to stop a wedding adds suspense.
The scenes of Gregory discussing love with Colin in a tree were particularly special, showing the supportive family dynamics.
4. An Offer from a Gentleman
In fourth place is An Offer from a Gentleman, a Cinderella retelling featuring Sophie and Benedict.
I love social class difference stories, and this one delivers. Sophie, a servant, meets Benedict at a masquerade, and their romance blossoms despite societal obstacles.
Benedict’s initial assumptions about their relationship add tension, making their eventual union satisfying. The iconic scenes and their chemistry make this book memorable.
3. The Viscount Who Loved Me
The Viscount Who Loved Me jumped to third place after my reread. Anthony and Kate’s romance is filled with banter, tension, and complexity.
Anthony’s fear of dying young and Kate’s phobia of thunderstorms bring depth to their characters. The library scene, the bee sting incident, and the Pall Mall game are iconic moments.
Kate’s insecurities and Anthony’s determination to win her over create a compelling dynamic.
2. To Sir Phillip, With Love
To Sir Phillip, With Love is probably the most controversial choice for second place. Eloise’s story diverges from her character in the show, but I adore the book version.
After the tragic death of his wife, Sir Phillip is left to raise his twins alone. Eloise, writing to him out of sympathy, decides to marry him, leading to humorous and heartfelt interactions.
The twins’ pranks and the developing romance between Eloise and Sir Phillip are highlights. Despite the dark beginning, the book’s charm and depth won me over.
1. When He Was Wicked
Finally, When He Was Wicked tops my list. Francesca, a lesser-seen Bridgerton sibling, stars in this emotionally charged story.
After losing her husband, she struggles with her feelings for Michael, her late husband’s cousin and best friend. Michael’s long-standing love for Francesca and the moral dilemma of pursuing her create intense drama and tension.
This book is the steamiest of the series and is filled with emotional depth. The pining and eventual resolution make it an unforgettable read.
Conclusion
Revisiting the Bridgerton series has been an enlightening experience, revealing how much my perspectives on the books have evolved.
I hope my rankings resonate with some of you, and I’m eager to hear your thoughts. Remember, everyone’s reading journey is unique, and our opinions can differ.
Let’s celebrate our love for the Bridgerton series together, appreciating the stories that have brought us so much joy.